As Congress considers a possible reconciliation package during the lame-duck session, lawmakers should pause and ask a basic question: if Americans are struggling with affordability, why would Washington respond by adding even more to the debt?
Reconciliation was created as a tool to reduce deficits, not increase them. Yet over the last decade, Congress has repeatedly used the process to fast-track legislation that adds trillions to the national debt with only a simple majority vote. If the new Congress is serious about fiscal responsibility and improving affordability for American families, one of its first priorities should be to not allow budget reconciliation bills to increase the deficit by restoring the “Conrad Rule,” named after former U.S. Senate Budget Chair Kent Conrad, that was in effect from 2007 to 2015.
As Conrad put it on the Concord Coalition’s podcast Facing the Future, “Reconciliation was designed for one purpose and one purpose only and that was to facilitate deficit reduction.” Today, he warned, it is being used in ways that “further explode the debt.”
A Lame-Duck Reconciliation Bill Moves in the Wrong Direction
Reports that Congress may consider another reconciliation package during the lame-duck session should concern anyone worried about the nation’s fiscal outlook. Regardless of the policy objectives, using reconciliation to increase deficits continues a bipartisan trend that has transformed what was intended to be a deficit-reduction tool into a shortcut for deficit-financing new spending and tax cuts.
Lawmakers often justify these measures as necessary to address economic challenges facing households. But there is a fundamental contradiction in that argument. Policies that increase deficits and debt can make affordability problems worse, not better.
Americans are already feeling the consequences of the nation’s deteriorating fiscal position. Higher federal borrowing increases demand for credit, putting upward pressure on interest rates. Those higher rates affect mortgages, auto loans, credit cards, and business investment. Families trying to buy homes, finance vehicles, or start businesses end up paying the price.
At the same time, persistent large deficits can contribute to inflationary pressures, especially when the economy is already operating near capacity. While inflation has moderated from its recent peak, prices are still growing faster than the Federal Reserve Board’s target rate. Adding more debt to the federal balance sheet is not a sustainable affordability strategy.
Reconciliation Has Drifted Far From Its Original Purpose
Reconciliation allows certain budget legislation to bypass the Senate filibuster and pass with a simple majority rather than the usual 60-vote threshold. It was created to facilitate deficit reduction by making it easier for Congress to enact spending reductions, tax increases and other budgetary savings.
The process has drifted in two important ways:
- Instead of encouraging fiscal discipline, it is increasingly used for deficit-increasing legislation.
- It is increasingly used to provide multi-year funding outside the regular appropriations process, reducing annual oversight and budget scrutiny.
These changes have weakened one of Congress’s most important budget enforcement mechanisms while contributing to a steady accumulation of federal debt.
A Bipartisan Pattern of Debt-Financed Reconciliation
Over the last decade, both parties have relied on reconciliation to enact legislation that added substantially to the debt. The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, the 2021 American Rescue Plan, and the 2025 One Big Beautiful Bill Act all used reconciliation procedures despite carrying significant fiscal costs. Together, these bills added trillions of dollars to projected federal borrowing.
Whatever the policy merits of any individual bill, the broader trend is unmistakable: reconciliation has become a vehicle for debt-financed policymaking rather than deficit reduction. A new reconciliation package during the lame-duck session would continue that pattern at precisely the moment Congress should be moving in the opposite direction.
Reviving the Conrad Rule
From 2007 to 2015, the Senate operated under what became known as the “Conrad Rule.” The rule prohibited reconciliation bills from increasing the deficit in the first year, fifth year, or tenth year of the budget window unless they could clear a 60-vote threshold.
The principle was straightforward: if Congress wanted to use reconciliation’s privileged procedures, the legislation should improve the fiscal outlook, not worsen it. According to Conrad, the rule “worked like a charm” because it prevented lawmakers from using reconciliation as a fast-track mechanism for deficit-financed legislation.
Restoring that safeguard would not prevent Congress from enacting major legislation. It would simply require broader bipartisan support for any reconciliation bill that increases deficits, while preserving reconciliation’s original role as a tool for fiscal improvement.
A Test for the New Congress
As a new Congress prepares to take office, lawmakers face a choice. They can continue the bipartisan pattern of using reconciliation to add to the debt, or they can begin rebuilding a culture of fiscal responsibility.
If Congress truly wants to improve affordability, strengthen economic growth, and prepare the nation for future challenges, it should start by recognizing that debt is part of the problem, not the solution.
Reviving the Conrad Rule would be an important first step. Reconciliation should once again be reserved for legislation that improves the nation’s fiscal outlook rather than legislation that deepens the debt and makes America’s affordability challenges even harder to solve.
Continue Reading